Reconsideration: How the First Disability Appeal Works

What is reconsideration in a Social Security disability claim?

Of the four appeal levels the Social Security Administration (SSA) lists, reconsideration comes first, right after a denial of Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) or Supplemental Security Income (SSI). The levels run in order: reconsideration, a hearing before an administrative law judge (ALJ), Appeals Council review, and a federal district court action. The full ladder is laid out on our disability appeals page.

At this stage SSA takes a second look at the same claim. SSA's appeals publication calls it “a complete review of your claim by someone who did not take part in the first determination.” When the denial was medical, that review happens at your state's Disability Determination Services (DDS), the state agency that handles medical disability issues for SSA.

The process runs on paper. For a denied application, the regulation calls it a case review: you get an opportunity to present additional evidence, and the reviewing official makes a new decision based on all of it. A separate track with a disability hearing applies to people who were already receiving disability benefits and were found no longer disabled on medical grounds. This guide covers the case review that follows a denied application.

The step is in use everywhere. SSA once tested a prototype in 10 states that skipped reconsideration for applications filed on or after October 1, 1999, and SSA's statistical report states that by March 31, 2020, the step had been reinstated in all 10 test states.

The file you build now does not stay at this level. If the answer is still no, it moves up to the hearing stage, and the work done here carries forward. That is why a reconsideration file is worth building as though a judge will read it next, which is planning, not pessimism. Our guide to what to expect at an ALJ hearing covers that next stage.

Back to contents

How long do you have to request reconsideration of a disability denial?

You have 60 days after the date you receive the denial notice to file a written request for reconsideration. The rule sits in 20 CFR 404.909, which requires the request to be in writing and filed at an SSA office, or at a Railroad Retirement Board office for people with 10 or more years of railroad service.

The clock does not start on the date printed on the letter. Under 20 CFR 404.901, the date you receive notice means 5 days after the date on the notice, unless you show you did not receive it within that 5-day period. For most people, that works out to 65 days from the date on the letter. Treat that last day the way you would treat the due date on a mortgage payment: the lender does not care that the check is in the mail, and neither does the calendar. If the last day falls on a weekend or a national holiday, SSA's appeals publication says the deadline moves to the next workday.

A missed date leaves one route back in, an extension for good cause, which we cover below. Filing early costs nothing and removes the question entirely.

SSA lets people denied for medical reasons request the appeal online. If you file on paper instead, SSA's form page lists Form SSA-561, Request for Reconsideration, and for medical decisions Form SSA-827, sent to your local Social Security office. SSA's page for Form SSA-3441, the Disability Report for appeals, lists it with the SSA-561 for anyone who does not appeal online.

Back to contents

Who reviews a disability claim at the reconsideration stage

A new reviewer at the state DDS decides a medical reconsideration, and that person took no part in the first decision. SSA states that rule in its appeals publication, and it applies to the medical side of SSDI and SSI claims alike. Nonmedical issues, such as overpayments, go to a local Social Security office or a payment center instead.

You do not meet the reviewer. Under 20 CFR 404.913, the case review gives you and any other party an opportunity to present additional evidence, and the official who reviews the case then makes a reconsidered determination based on all of that evidence. There is no testimony and no hearing room at this level.

That shapes what helps. A reviewer who has never met you can only weigh what is written down, so vague descriptions lose ground to specific ones. A reconsideration is not a second vote on the same paperwork. It is a fresh review, and new records are what give the reviewer something different to weigh.

The reviewer also applies the same medical rules as the first examiner. Terms like residual functional capacity and substantial gainful activity come up in both decisions, and our glossary defines them in plain English.

Back to contents

What to add to your disability claim file before reconsideration

Add anything that has happened medically since the first decision, and anything the first examiner did not have. Presenting additional evidence is the opportunity the case review rule gives you, and it is the main lever you hold at this stage.

Start with the reason stated in the denial notice and build toward it. If the notice says your condition is not severe enough to keep you from working, the records you add should show, in concrete terms, what you cannot do. Our page on disability denials walks through what a denial letter means and what comes next.

• New treatment records. Office visits, imaging, lab work, hospital stays and therapy notes dated after your application, from every provider.
• New providers and new diagnoses. List each one on the appeal disability report so SSA can request the records.
• Medication changes and side effects. Dosage changes, new prescriptions and documented side effects show what treatment has and has not done.
• Statements about function. A letter from a treating provider describing specific limits, such as how long you can sit, stand, lift or concentrate, says more than a diagnosis alone.
• Work changes. If you stopped working, cut hours, or tried and failed to return, write down the dates.

Keep every detail accurate. A reviewer compares what you report with the records, and an overstatement that the records contradict does more harm than the limitation it was meant to describe. Plain, documented facts carry the claim further than adjectives do.

Back to contents

Can you still appeal a disability denial after 60 days?

Yes, if you can show good cause for missing the deadline. Under 20 CFR 404.909(b), you ask SSA in writing for more time, and the request must give the reasons the reconsideration was not filed on time. If SSA finds good cause, it extends the period.

SSA judges good cause under 20 CFR 404.911. The factors include the circumstances that kept you from filing, whether something SSA did misled you, whether you misunderstood the requirements because of changes in the law or court rulings, and any physical, mental, educational or language limitations that kept you from filing on time or from knowing you needed to.

The regulation lists examples where good cause may exist, such as:

• A serious illness that kept you from contacting SSA in any way, including through someone else.
• A death or serious illness in your immediate family.
• Important records destroyed or damaged by fire or another accident.
• Searching diligently for supporting information you could not find in time.
• SSA giving you incorrect or incomplete information about how or when to appeal.
• Sending the request in good faith to another government agency within the deadline, where it reached SSA too late.
• Unusual or unavoidable circumstances that kept you from filing or from knowing you needed to.

File the late request together with the reconsideration itself, explain the reason with plain dates and facts, and attach proof such as hospital discharge papers or a death certificate. A good cause claim is an explanation SSA weighs, not an automatic extension, so the documents matter as much as the story.

Back to contents