What Is a Social Security Consultative Exam and Why Was One Scheduled?

What is a consultative exam for a disability claim?

Expect a medical appointment that Social Security arranges and pays for, not a visit you set up yourself. The federal regulation at 20 CFR 404.1519 defines a consultative examination as a physical or mental examination or test purchased for you at SSA's request and expense. The Social Security Administration (SSA) uses it in claims for Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI), and the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) rules in Part 416 of the same title follow the same pattern.

Most exams are arranged by Disability Determination Services (DDS), the state agency that develops the medical evidence and makes the initial disability decision on a claim for SSA. Under 20 CFR 404.1517, SSA must give you reasonable notice of the date, time and place of the exam and the name of the person who will perform it, and it gives the examiner background on your condition before you arrive.

The letter scheduling the exam is not a decision on your claim. It tells you that the file, as it stands, is missing something the examiner can supply. It is the medical version of a lender ordering its own appraisal before approving a loan: the appraiser works from what the lender needs to know, and the report goes to the lender.

Back to contents

Why SSA schedules a consultative exam for your claim

SSA generally tries your own medical sources first, and it buys an exam when it cannot get the information it needs from them. That is the rule at 20 CFR 404.1519a, which also requires DDS to review the reports already in your file and the allegations you made on your disability forms before purchasing one.

The regulation describes two broad triggers: an inconsistency in the evidence that needs to be resolved, or evidence that as a whole is not enough to make a determination. It lists common situations, including these:

• The evidence SSA needs is not in your medical sources' records.
• Records cannot be obtained for reasons beyond your control, such as a provider's death or noncooperation.
• Highly technical or specialized evidence is needed and your providers do not have it.
• There are signs your condition has changed in a way likely to affect your ability to work, but its current severity is not established.

In practice, a common gap is time. A claimant who has not seen a doctor in months, or who has seen only a primary care provider for a condition that calls for specialist findings, leaves DDS without current evidence. The steps on our applying for disability page about listing every provider and treatment date are the same steps that keep an exam from being needed in the first place.

Back to contents

Who performs a Social Security disability exam

Only a qualified medical source can perform a consultative exam, and SSA's guidance for health professionals says your own treating source is the preferred source when that provider is qualified, equipped and willing to do it. SSA's consultative examination guidelines state that the source may be your own physician or psychologist or another source, and that DDS turns to an independent examiner in situations such as when your treating source prefers not to perform the exam.

A qualified source must hold a current state license, have the training and experience to perform the specific exam or test, and have the equipment the assessment needs. Assistants such as X-ray technicians or nurses may help, but they must meet their state's licensing or certification rules. When DDS chooses an examiner, distance from your home is generally one of the factors, along with appointment availability and the examiner's ability to perform the needed tests.

Some exams can be done by video. Under SSA's operating manual, DDS may schedule a telehealth exam for psychiatric exams, psychological exams without standardized testing, and speech and language exams, but only if you agree to it. You need a private, quiet space, a reliable internet connection and a device with a camera and microphone, and an adult without a valid government-issued photo ID is scheduled in person instead.

Back to contents

What happens at a consultative exam appointment

Plan on a focused exam built around SSA's questions, and arrive with the items the notice lists. SSA's operating manual at POMS DI 22510.016 says the appointment notice must explain why the exam is needed, give the examiner's name and address and the date and time, and remind you to bring:

• Current, valid government identification, preferably with a photo.
• All of your medications in their original containers.
• Medical aids you use, such as eyeglasses, hearing aids or assistive devices.

The notice also asks you to confirm that you will attend and to say whether you need an interpreter. SSA's guidelines state that DDS provides an interpreter free of charge to anyone who requests language assistance.

The regulations set the minimum time an examiner must schedule for you: at least 30 minutes for a full general medical exam, 20 minutes for a full musculoskeletal or neurological exam, 40 minutes for a full psychiatric exam and 60 minutes for a psychological exam. Those are scheduling minimums, not a promise of how long the exam will run.

The examiner then writes a report. Under 20 CFR 404.1519n, a complete report covers your main complaints and their history, the positive and negative findings, any test results, a diagnosis and prognosis, and usually a medical opinion. SSA's guidelines say an adult's report should describe your ability to do basic work-related activities, based on the examiner's own findings, but should not state whether you are disabled. That decision stays with SSA, which uses the report in assessing your residual functional capacity. Describe your symptoms the way they are on an ordinary day, and include the help you get from other people.

Back to contents

What happens if you miss a Social Security consultative exam?

Missing the exam without a good reason can lead to a denial. Under 20 CFR 404.1518, if you are applying for benefits and have no good reason for failing to appear, SSA may find that you are not disabled. The same rule tells you to notify SSA as soon as possible before the appointment if you cannot attend, and SSA considers any physical, mental, educational or language limitations in deciding whether your reason was good.

The regulation gives these examples of good reasons:

• Illness on the date of the scheduled exam.
• Not receiving timely notice, or any notice, of the appointment.
• Receiving incorrect or incomplete information about the examiner, the date, the time or the place.
• A death or serious illness in your immediate family.

If you have a good reason, SSA schedules another exam. Timing matters, though. SSA's operating manual says a missed exam is generally not rescheduled unless you or your representative call before the case is finished and give a good reason. Once DDS has made the required contact attempts and developed your medical history from your existing sources, it can decide the claim on the evidence in the file. Missing a scheduled exam is one of the reasons we cover in our guide to why disability claims are denied. If one of your own doctors advises you not to take a particular exam or test, the regulation tells you to let SSA know right away so it can look for the information another way.

Back to contents

How much the consultative exam counts in your disability claim

The exam report is one piece of evidence, weighed by the same rules as every other medical opinion in your file. For claims filed on or after March 27, 2017, 20 CFR 404.1520c says SSA does not defer to or give controlling weight to any medical opinion, including one from your own doctor. The two most important factors are supportability, meaning how well the opinion is backed by objective findings and explanation, and consistency, meaning how well it fits the rest of the evidence.

The regulation also lists the source's relationship with you as a factor, including the length of the treatment relationship, how often the source examined you and whether the source examined you at all. A consultative examiner often sees you only once. Your own providers can show how a condition behaves over months and years, through flare-ups, medication changes and bad weeks that a single appointment will not capture.

That is why the exam should not replace your regular care. Keep your appointments with your own providers, ask them to record your functional limits in their notes, and make sure SSA has their names and dates. When the exam findings conflict with a long treatment record, the consistency and supportability factors are where that conflict gets weighed.

Back to contents